Deborah Bakker is currently working at the Zero Emissions Research and Initiatives (ZERI) pavilion at EXPO 2000, the World’s Fair in Hannover, Germany. Previously she worked for the International Institute for Sustainable Development. Originally hailing from Ottawa, she currently calls Winnipeg, Manitoba, home.
Monday, 16 Oct 2000
HANNOVER, Germany
I’ve been here for just over a week, working at the Zero Emissions Research and Initiatives (ZERI) pavilion at the World’s Fair. The ZERI Foundation is a nonprofit organization established in 1996 in Geneva, Switzerland, with seven regional field offices scattered around the globe. The foundation’s goal is to encourage the efficient production of goods and services without any form of waste — no liquid waste, no gaseous waste, and no solid waste. Seven showcase ZERI projects are currently being displayed at our pavilion.
Today I am making final preparations for ZERI’s “International Day,” working with our press coordinator, a Swedish woman named Anna. Every day here at the EXPO, one pavilion is profiled, and tomorrow it will be ours. It’s basically a day for dignitaries and official ceremonies, for VIPs, ministers, and pavilion general commissioners to visit. It’s also a day for special presentations, tours, and cultural performances. Unlike other pavilions, ZERI’s doesn’t represent a country, but the “International Day” moniker is still being used to describe our big day.
Anna and I scoot about the sprawling EXPO grounds on our kickboards, confirming guided tours for the VIPs who will be visiting us tomorrow and checking in at the pavilions that have agreed to send a performer for the day-long cultural program we’re organizing. We have a stage booked with artists and musicians from 10 countries — including a Rajasthani dance troupe, the Pied Piper from Hameln, a drummer from the Central African Republic, Mexican balladeers, and Fijian fire dancers. Anna speaks four languages fluently (English, German, Spanish, and Swedish). I do the talking at all of the pavilions from French Africa.
Of course things take longer than we anticipate. Anna and I have a schedule; we intend to spend 30 minutes at each pavilion that we have to visit today, which includes transportation time. But when we walk to the African pavilions, time slows down. We must do business the African way, which fellow ZERI guides from Togo and Ivory Coast have told us about. We speak to Pierre at the Benin pavilion for a few minutes before finally getting to the point. We’d like to visit with his colleague who has worked with one of ZERI’s contacts — the Songhai Institute, a development NGO (non-governmental organization) in Benin that’s a center for research and training in sustainable agriculture, a common theme in ZERI projects. She’ll be back in 30 minutes. We wander over to the Uganda pavilion to visit Anna’s friend in the interim and stroll back through the market filled with throngs of goods and people.
When we return Ms. Amelie Assogba is there. She greets us warmly. I feel underdressed in my chinos and sneakers. Everyone here is wearing a suit or skirt. We go upstairs and sit down. I do most of the talking in French and translate for Anna. If you don’t mind, Amelie starts, can I ask you a few questions before we begin? Where are you from? What do you do? Why are you working for ZERI? Oh, that’s very interesting, may I get a copy of your thesis? After this introductory conversation, I reciprocate and ask her a few questions about herself. We finally get to the point of our visit. She did receive the invitation we sent out last week to present at the pavilion and would be interested in coming tomorrow. We discuss the structure and format of the talk, to be translated simultaneously. She takes us downstairs to show us art made from reclaimed metal and products made from waste tires and talk a little bit about environmental issues, sustainable development, and social and environmental problems in Benin, and how all of these relate to the displays at the pavilion. All three of us exchange addresses, get introduced to more people, and then say our goodbyes, which take a few minutes for each person.
Back at the pavilion I’m reminded of the adrenaline rush before other big events I’ve been involved in organizing. Did you call the Bolivian pavilion or did someone else? Where did you put the VIP delegation list? Press releases must be written and translated. Ingredients for breakfast must be bought. Signs must be made that say “Kein Engang” and “Geschlöten für 45 minuten” for those periods when the second level and bar will be closed off to visitors. The man at the copy shop knows us well.
We finally leave at about 11 p.m. During the 30-minute train ride back to the staff apartments, I have time to reflect and read more in the book Upsizing by Gunter Pauli, the founder and director of ZERI. News stories from home are few and far between. I understand only a smattering of the German radio. I vow to look for an English language paper, or to spend some time surfing the Internet for online news (if I can get to a computer) tomorrow.
Tuesday, 17 Oct 2000
HANNOVER, Germany
I get a late start this morning but manage to run for the tram and grab a little food for the road, for a day I’ve been helping to prepare for since I arrived. How long ago? It seems like weeks but it’s only been a few days. Having a routine to settle into — taking the same tram every morning from the apartments that ZERI has rented for staff, winding through narrow Hannover streets to the EXPO site — has helped life here seem immediately “normal.”
Chillin’ at the pavilion.
ZERI.
Amid a cool breeze and dissipating clouds in the stunning open-air setting on the second floor of ZERI’s bamboo pavilion, Gunter Pauli starts the day with a lecture entitled “The five kingdoms of nature and the ZERI model of wealth generation.” Others trickle in, so I don’t feel so bad about my tardiness. The group settles down at the huge table, piling under coats and blankets, warming our socked feet (there’s a strict no-shoe rule on the second floor).
The lecture covers a bit of the history of ZERI and its role. ZERI, founded in 1996, is officially an NGO based in Switzerland, and now a foundation based in Hannover, Germany. I’ve worked for organizations whose primary role is research and, to a lesser extent, advocacy, but the difference that I see in ZERI is (a) that its most important resource — the incredible array of people in its network — are so geographically disbursed and (b) that it has the ability to nurture innovative ideas. In the broader sense, I see ZERI as a facilitator and an idea node, helping to realize practical projects.
The theory from Gunter’s book, Upsizing, including concepts of immunity management and generative science, provides a little bit of the background for the lecture. He suggests a new standard for assessing whether an industrial system is working at its optimal level — seeing if it involves all five kingdoms of nature — and he illustrates with an example.
The fungus among us.
Wednesday, 18 Oct 2000
HANNOVER, Germany
Today was supposed to be my day off, a day to be spent sleeping, exploring Hannover, and catching up on long-lapsed correspondence home. Would that it were so easy. To all my friends and family who I told I would write — my apologies.
My plans were foiled by what’s turning out to be one of the busiest weeks here at the ZERI pavilion and at the EXPO. Don’t Germans work? To my chagrin, I missed Michael McBride’s presentation on the first eco-brewery in Canada, but I was filled in later in the day.
Michael was inspired to start his do-it-yourself degree in mycology and beer after attending a ZERI meeting in Namibia in 1996, where he came to the conclusion that if mushrooms could be grown on beer waste in the desert in Namibia, it could be done in Newfoundland. He now cultivates high-priced oyster and shiitake mushrooms on spent grain from his Stormbrewing Brewery outside of St. John’s, Newfoundland.
Conventional brewing processes use about 20 liters of water for every liter of beer brewed, and produce about 18.5 kilograms of malted barley (or other grain) as waste. Only 8 percent of barley is typically used in the brewing process; the remaining grain has high amounts of lignin cellulose fiber and protein, and, although it is often fed directly to cattle, it’s actually difficult for ruminants to digest.
A solution? Mushrooms. Through years of experience, ZERI researchers — in particular professor George Chan — have developed a way to break down the lignin cellulose, making it easier for cattle to digest and creating economic value at the same time. Some projects — which are spread around the world from Fiji to Columbia, from Namibia to Mauritius — grow shiitake mushrooms, already a $2.4 billion industry worldwide, but you can also cultivate oyster mushrooms, reishi, or any number of valuable fungi. In fact a common thread among ZERI projects is to use mushrooms to transform conventional organic waste into more valuable products — from economic, social, and environmental perspectives.
I’m never going to look at boring button mushrooms in the grocery store in the same way. One of the guides here is a very knowledgeable mycologist from Brazil, and the other night I flipped through the catalogue of a mushroom supply company based in Olympia, Wash., Fungi Perfecti. Definitely a place I’ll visit when I’m back in that part of the world.
But these systems I’m describing aren’t simple linear ones. And that’s the beauty of them. They’re diverse, incredibly complex, and consist of many different parts, just like natural systems. The brewery in Namibia is akin to an ecosystem — chickens are raised, eight different varieties of fish are grown in wastewater treatment ponds, and protein-rich algae are grown in ponds and harvested (remember this the next time you’re see bottles of green drinks in a natural foods store or spot an ad extolling the vigor-inducing properties of spirulina).
When I think of these projects, I’m continually reminded that economies and ecological systems both need complexity and proper scale to be resilient and sustainable.
Some of the rest of the day is taken up by minutiae, socializing, and writing. Lunch is served and we congregate outside on the gravel beside the Sri Lanka pavilion. I learn a few more words of Spanish and we make plans for a tour of the Canadian pavilion on Friday and a party at the pavilion later that night.
There’s a completely different air at the ZERI pavilion than at other pavilions. Part of it is our small size, but it might also be because much of the day is spent in the open air, if not directly outside, or because of the big mural of humpback whales that we can see when we walk around, or because of the closeness and warmth of the staff. The cold and rain remind me of the west coast at home, and I complain sometimes, but on warmer sunny autumn days it’s wonderful.
Later in the afternoon a group of us leaves to visit an ecological community near the EXPO site. I’m amazed at the impeccable neatness of the farm. Never having been on a European farm, I’m not sure if it is geography or culture that is the reason for this. Human waste is treated with an onsite wetland, and waste from pigs and chickens and cows as well as waste from the slaughterhouse goes to a digester where it is decomposed anaerobically, producing the methane gas that provides the energy for the complex, where about 15 people live. When I learn that it’s an example built expressly for the EXPO, I’m not surprised at the spanking new feel to everything.
The sunset is phenomenal. We look to the east, where three Danish-designed windmills form a perfectly composed scene lined up against the light blue sky and pale flat fields. We pause at the top of a grassy knoll created as a sound barrier against the freeway that abuts the complex. It’s great to hear wind and grass again, since the background noise at the pavilion is pounding Euro-techno from neighboring pavilions and voices speaking in languages I don’t completely understand. Then the group of us heads back inside to test the beer brewed on site and back to the pavilion for our ride home.
Another educational seminar tomorrow morning should mean an early night, always an effort he
re since the company is so great.
Thursday, 19 Oct 2000
HANNOVER, Germany
For the first time in about a week, it’s sunny at 8:30 a.m. The pavilion looks stunning in this morning light, since it’s coming in at a sharp angle from the east, and I take a few pictures. The two-story round building, modeled after a mushroom, is airy and open. It was designed by Colombian architect Simon Velez, considered by many to be a world expert in bamboo architecture and construction.
I go upstairs to find a notebook I left there yesterday and spend a few minutes swinging in the hammock from Colombia, looking up at the exposed beams in the ceiling, before heading downstairs to meet others arriving for the seminar. The flooring here on the second floor of the pavilion is made from Thai bamboo by a German company, Elephant Parkett, and there’s also a large table used for meetings and seminars, a few bamboo plants sitting against the sides, and a few computers, ostensibly linking to the ZERI website, except they haven’t been working for the past few days. In a few weeks the second floor will be transformed into a Japanese Zen space and monks will be here for the day. I only hope that it’s this beautiful for the monks’ ceremonies.
A group of us walks over to the 3,600-square-meter Japanese pavilion next door, made almost entirely out of recycled paper and a cardboard frame, where we’re having this morning’s seminar. After staring at the outside of the building from the ZERI pavilion for two weeks, I’m finally getting to go inside. The gently vaulted roof is a graceful arched lattice made of thick paper tubes and steel, covered with a layer of special fire-resistant, waterproof paper which allows light to pass through.
Typical of what seems to be the unofficial modus operandi here at the EXPO, the person at the door knows nothing about our intended arrival and plans to use the conference room for something else, and everything is a bit chaotic for a few minutes. We finally find the right person and get escorted up to the conference room, sparely furnished, thoroughly supplied, and extremely neat and tidy. I sit down close to the rose placed on the table, and I think all of us in the group, about 25 in total, are glad to be inside after sitting outside for the rest of the week’s seminars. I make a mental note to myself to try and get some slippers before the next seminars.
Graham Harper, who works with ZERI Link in Japan, talks about his experiences and we all share our views about environmental education. ZERI Link is an educational program that creates and distributes curriculum for high school students based on the ZERI principles, and connects students with local companies so they can apply what they learn in the classroom. There are parallel programs operating in Sweden (at least six guides here have participated in that program), England, Japan, and, in a few months, Thailand, with some plans to develop programs in Italy and Canada. The programs are a bit ad hoc, varying in structure and size from country to country, but they all have the common elements of creating a dialogue between the corporate sector and high school students, allowing the students to gain practical experience in the theory behind ZERI.
In the Japanese program, Graham’s English class worked with Shiseido Cosmetics, identifying waste streams and trying to suggest ways of making industrial clusters and creating value from innovative uses of the company’s waste. Graham tells the story of how much of an impact the students’ work had. After listening to the students’ presentation of their final report, one of the senior executives expressed his epiphany out loud, saying that perhaps it was time for the company to change its ways. It’s impressive that a group of schoolgirls could have such an effect.
After the education seminar we wander back to the pavilion. I have a stimulating conversation with someone from New Zealand about the importance of experiential education, particularly in environmental education, but also in online education. All this thinking makes me thirsty and I get a couple of beers from the bar (not very unusual here, since Germans start ordering beer as soon as we open at 9 a.m.) and we continue talking and move on to our EXPO misgivings.
The fair is supposed to radiate with the themes of Humankind, Nature, and Technology. But most days I see an enormous consumer fest — a summer fair like those they have at home minus the carnies, with better coffee, pretzel carts instead of cotton candy, and more stylish people. Take for instance the Andorran pavilion, one of the most prominent here, representing one of the smallest countries at the EXPO. They’ve done a superb marketing job, since almost every 10th person has a pin or bag from the pavilion’s gift shop, but their pavilion contains little about technology, sustainable development, or nature. Cynicism aside, there are some gems here, including the ZERI pavilion, and the Finnish and Bhutanese pavilions.
Back to work at the bar and information booth. Customers like the menu — a variety of toasted sandwiches, coffeecake, beer, good strong Colombian coffee that comes from a ZERI project, and homemade lemonade. The sandwich bread and the coffeecake are both made from spent grain from the brewery in Cologne where we get the beer.
Finally, at about 10 p.m., a group of us leaves for one of the big concert halls here for a free show by the Buena Vista Social Club. Arriba!
