Photos: Ed Bruske
Every day, U.S. schoolchildren throw tons of vegetables in the trash.
The USDA requires that schools participating in the National School Lunch Program offer a certain quantity of vegetables each week. But most schools serve processed foods that arrive frozen and get reheated. Vegetables typically land on students’ cafeteria trays overcooked and unpalatable. Who can blame them for turning up their noses?
School-food reformer Ann Cooper puts her vegetable money in salad bars, where the lettuce is always crisp and the vegetables only lightly blanched or roasted, if cooked at all. Before Cooper arrived in Boulder to take over food services, the schools were gradually beginning to introduce what they called “Harvest Bars.” One of Cooper’s first acts was to install a salad bar in all 48 of the district’s schools.
“When salad bars are set up correctly, they give kids choices, and it’s healthy, or certainly can be,” says Cooper. “That’s not to say there isn’t waste from salad bars. And if I had the money, I would do both: serve vegetables in the food line and at the salad bar. But when you let kids actively choose what they want, the more likely it is that they will actively eat the food.”
While in Boulder, Cooper met a parent activist — Mara Fleishman — who also happens to be Whole Foods Market’s national partnership director. What followed was a salad bar campaign — the Great American Salad Bar Project — through which Whole Foods recently raised $1.4 million from customers nationwide, enough to install salad bars in 564 schools. Around 570 schools have applied. And on Nov. 22, First Lady Michelle Obama announced that a new public-private partnership, Let’s Move Salad Bars to Schools, would provide funding for at least 6,000 more new salad bars for U.S. school cafeterias.
Petri dishing it out
But while studies suggest that salad bars can help boost children’s consumption of fruits and vegetables, some school districts have declined to install salad bars, claiming they’re unsanitary, especially for elementary-school students with active hands and faces that often come up short of the cough-and-sneeze barriers. In addition, a memo circulated by the USDA in October encouraging the use of salad bars reminded schools that in order to comply with federal regulations, cafeteria cashiers were supposed to check that students took the prescribed portions of fruits and vegetables when they serve themselves.
“Part of the difficulty of dealing with the USDA is they’re trying to oversee 10,000 school districts, so they have all these rules — rules and rules and rules and rules,” Cooper said. “And it just doesn’t work on the ground. If you make kids pass by the cash register after they’ve been to the salad bar, it just slows everything down.”
She acknowledges some uncertainly around the question of how local health inspectors might treat salad bars in schools scattered around the country. But she disputes the notion that salad bars pose a potential health hazard. “As far as I’ve found out, there are no documented disease outbreaks from school salad bars. By and large, this is not a high risk area,” she said. Still, she named several jurisdictions that, for one reason or another, will not allow salad bars, including Philadelphia, Austin, Texas, and Montgomery County, Md., just outside Washington, D.C. and the White House where Michelle Obama is trying to get the nation’s kids to eat more vegetables as a way of combating childhood obesity.
Montgomery County, otherwise considered one of the more progressive jurisdictions in the country, also does not permit food gardens on school grounds, claiming they might attract rodents and other vermin.
“We have salad bars at some of our high schools, although not many,” said Dana Tofig, spokesman for Montgomery County schools. “Since salad bars do not fit USDA guidelines (as pointed out in your columns) they are an á la carte item. So students who want to eat from the salad bar, including kids who receive free and reduced-price meals (FARMS), have to pay for them. In some schools, we have had to close down salad bars because they do not cover expenses and we end up wasting food.”
Tofig added: “We do offer premade salads that meet USDA guidelines in all secondary schools. These salads do qualify for federal reimbursement for the 30 percent of our students who receive FARMS subsidies.”
In the District of Columbia, where my daughter attends school, meanwhile, officials have said they are anxious to install salad bars in local schools. Several D.C. schools have applied for grants from the Whole Foods campaign that Cooper is managing.
Others have said they don’t have the sinks or dishwashing equipment to manage salad bars. But Cooper counters that lettuce and other vegetables can be purchased pre-cut and pre-washed, and that food dispensers in the salad bars can be equipped with disposable liners, or washed in bus tubs. “There’s a way to work around those issues,” Cooper said.
I wanted to make salad bars a major focus of my week in Boulder, because they seem to be a logical way of encouraging children to eat more vegetables, as opposed to the cooked-to-death broccoli they’re typically served. Farm-to-school programs have sprouted all over the country attempting to integrate local farm produce into schools. Salad bars are an obvious candidate to be an outlet for local fruits and vegetables.
It turns out there’s really nothing very complicated about salad bars. In the Boulder school district’s five production kitchens, cooks peel, slice, and chop fresh vegetables such as celery, cucumbers, carrots, red pepper, and jicama, and ship them off in plastic containers called “fish tubs” to satellite kitchens in 48 schools. There, kitchen workers transfer them to in-house containers and label them with a date.
At the appropriate hour before lunch service, a kitchen worker begins assembling the salad bar using the fresh vegetables as well as any number of other food items: canned kidney beans, chickpeas, tuna salad, egg salad, hard-boiled eggs, pickled jalapeno, cherry tomatoes, diced chicken, lettuce, and cottage cheese. While I was there, the kitchens were using packaged Romaine lettuce, prewashed and prechopped from Dole, because the usual bulk “spring mix” from California had been sub-par lately, Cooper said. Frozen peas and frozen corn kernels, once thawed, also appear on the salad bar, along with three dressings displayed in squirt bottles, ranch being the hands-down favorite over Italian and balsamic. In theory, a student could compose a complete meal at the salad bar and that would be perfectly fine with the USDA — as long as a kitchen worker checked to make sure all the required components were in place before approving it as a reimbursable meal.
One recent salad bar innovation: tabbouleh, a Middle Eastern salad of whole-grain bulgar wheat and parsley. It appears on days when pizza is served
because the commercial pizza crust Boulder kitchens currently use is not whole grain. “A kid asked me what it was. He didn’t seem quite sure about it,” said Yuri Sanow, sous chef at Monarch High School. “I explained to him what tabbouleh was. A few days later, I see the same kid and one of his friends asks him, ‘What’s that?’ And the kids says, ‘Oh, that’s taboulleh. You should try it.'”
At Boulder’s Columbine Elementary School, I experienced for the first time the sight of kindergarteners serving themselves from the salad bar. They did so with relish. “They’re really into it because it’s new for them,” said Columbine’s “kitchen lead,” Margaret Trevarton. “By the time they get to fifth grade, the bloom is off the rose.”
In fact, the older kids seemed to be less interested in the salad bar. “That’s because we’re out of ranch dressing,” said kitchen worker Tammy Steele, who was in charge of the salad bar that day. “When we have ranch dressing, there are four times as many kids at the salad bar.”
Sometimes the kids get encouragement to try things they may not be used to. Erica Goodman, a graduate student in media studies at the University of Colorado, Boulder, volunteers in the local schools as part of a campaign to boost participation in the subsidized meal program. Sometimes at elementary schools, she simply stands by the salad bar and challenges kids to fill their plates.
“I’ll tell them, ‘Today’s challenge is to see who can make the most colorful salad,’ or maybe, ‘Who can make a salad with the most variety?'” Goodman said. “It really works. Until you get to the fifth grade and then the kids want to know what they get if they win the challenge.”
In the upper grades, not all kids take a salad, but from what I observed, enough do to make the salad bars worthwhile. Lunch in the high schools appeared to be a busy time around the salad bars. Teenagers were not at all shy about loading their trays.
Under USDA rules, schools who use the so-called “food-based meal plan,” as in Boulder, must offer students five lunch items covering basic food groups, plus milk. They are only required to take three of these to qualify as a “meal” for purposes of federal reimbursements. For example, nachos with chips, a scoop of taco filling, and a topping of grated cheese would qualify. But then students can pour their own milk if they choose from a dispenser, and help themselves to unlimited amounts from the salad bar, where whole fruit also is displayed.
“Hey, do you have any of that egg salad?” asked a teenage girl in the food line at Monarch High School. “That stuff is awesome. You should have it more often.”
Beth Collins, Ann Cooper’s business partner who’s been in charge of procurement for the school kitchens, says she knows the kids are eating more fruits and vegetables. “We’re spending $40,000 a month on produce, mostly for the salad bars,” Collins said. “Before, they were spending $70,000 for the entire year.”
Says parent and school-food activist Mara Fleishman: “My kids are now eating at the schools five days a week, and I can be assured they are going to eat fresh vegetables every day because of the salad bar. They love the choice. They love the empowerment.”