Wind energy and birds: Can’t have one without decapitating the other, apparently! That’s more or less the shared position of two prominent American egomaniacs, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump and author Jonathan Franzen.

Never mind that coal and oil have a worse track record when it comes to avian death. But what are the nuances of each man’s position on the ever-present conflict between turbines and tanagers? Can you identify them?

See if you can correctly attribute the quotes below! Answers after the jump.