CityOne screen grabIBM is hyping its new flash video game, OneCity, which is sort of a hybrid between SimCity and a well-produced product pitch. Rather than building a metropolis from scratch, as in SimCity, players inherit a picturesque mountain city and try to fix problem scenarios that arise in four areas — energy, water, banking and retail. Never mind that urban leaders don’t actually control banking and retail — these four are the categories in which IBM has products to sell.

From Next American City:

Once players complete 10 rounds, the game provides an assessment of your performance, and classifies you as one of five types of leaders – pragmatic, conservative, short-term oriented, futurist or evasive (if you happen to “ignore the problem” too many times).

Reader support makes our work possible. Donate today to keep our climate news free. All donations matched!

… Obviously, investing in smart and customer focused technology and processes is probably going to be a good thing for many cities – as it has been for many businesses. But for all the media hype (and the undoubted brain power of IBM), CityOne seems a bit too simplistic. Playing the game, the budget rarely seems to be a problem … And there are too many obvious choices (i.e: to protect water supplies from terrorists, should you a) create an advisory board; b) test the water more regularly; or c) invest in “advanced smart water monitoring” – with choice “c” being the cheapest. Duh!).

Grist thanks its sponsors. Become one.

Not surprisingly, the game tends to reward choices that involve investing in information technology networks — IBM’s forté. It’s somewhat illuminating to learn about the ways a cities can inject IT into their energy, water, and commercial systems. But it’s also somewhat like a 30-minute IBM commercial.

After that glowing recommendation, you can go play the game for free.

Here’s the trailer:

Grist thanks its sponsors. Become one.