Dave gives Obama’s speech short shrift. I would argue that this speech — taking it to the automakers on their home turf, apparently to some applause — is a big-time deal. The same could be said of the speech what Dave wrote in starry-eyed fashion when the outlines of the TXU deal became public: "The ‘tipping point’ concept is cheap from overuse these days, but to me this is the clearest sign yet that we have entered a fundamentally new stage in the fight against global warming."

Sure, the policy recommendations behind the speech may not be the boldest out there, but can you imagine a presidential candidate giving this speech even a year ago, let alone at this point in 2003? In 1999, Gore was running as hard as he could from Earth-in-the-Balance-like proclamations like this one by Obama today: "The auto industry’s refusal to act for so long has left it mired in a predicament for which there is no easy way out."

Grist relies on the support of generous readers like you. Donate today to keep our climate news free.

I’m interested in others’ thoughts. And keep your eyes on Grist — as the race heats up, we will be conducting the definitive green interviews with presidential contenders.

Grist thanks its sponsors. Become one.